Jones Act Defense Attorney

Jones Act Defense Attorney

When a crew member sues your company or a federal agency questions how your vessel moved cargo, the law at the center is often the Jones Act. That name covers two federal laws, one letting an injured seaman sue the employer and one limiting shipping between U.S. ports to qualifying U.S. vessels. A Jones Act defense attorney represents the company, vessel owner, operator, or executive on the receiving end, where some key deadlines run in months, not years.

At Hilder & Associates, P.C., we defend companies, vessel owners and operators, and individual executives in these matters; we do not represent injured seamen. Our Houston firm is led by former federal prosecutor Philip H. Hilder, and our attorneys can respond immediately when a claim, penalty notice, or federal inquiry arrives. Call [phonenumber] or contact us to schedule a free consultation.

Jones Act Claims, Penalties, and Investigations We Defend

Jones Act Claims, Penalties, and Investigations We Defend

One voyage can create several kinds of exposure:

  • Crew injury litigation: Under Section 30104 of Title 46 of the U.S. Code, a seaman injured on the job may sue the employer before a jury.
  • Coastwise trade enforcement: When merchandise or passengers move between U.S. points on a vessel that does not qualify, U.S. Customs and Border Protection (CBP) can seize the merchandise or assess penalties.
  • Federal investigations: A serious casualty, a death aboard, or a questioned cargo movement can draw a Coast Guard, CBP, or Justice Department inquiry.

With several agencies involved, we work to intervene early, before a claim or inquiry escalates.

Who Counts as a Seaman Under the Jones Act?

Only a seaman can bring a Jones Act claim. In Chandris, Inc. v. Latsis, the U.S. Supreme Court’s majority opinion set a two-part test. First, the worker’s duties must contribute to the function of the vessel or to the accomplishment of its mission. Second, the worker must have a connection to a vessel in navigation, or to an identifiable group of such vessels, that is substantial in both its duration and its nature. As a guideline, not a bright line, the Court said a worker spending less than about 30% of working time in the service of a vessel in navigation should not qualify.

A worker who falls outside this test has no Jones Act claim, whatever happened aboard, which makes seaman status a threshold question in the defense.

What Negligence Standard Does the Jones Act Apply?

A Jones Act claim turns on negligence, meaning a failure to use reasonable care. The Act borrows the Federal Employers’ Liability Act, the federal law for injured railway workers, so fault and causation follow railroad injury law, not state negligence rules. Under that law, an employer can be liable if its negligence played any part, even the slightest, in causing the injury.

Section 53 of Title 45 of the U.S. Code provides that a worker’s own negligence does not bar recovery, but the jury reduces damages in proportion to the worker’s share of the negligence. That reduction does not apply when the employer violated a statute enacted for the safety of employees and the violation contributed to the injury or death.

With causation that easy to show, the voyage record (logs, crew statements, maintenance and inspection records) matters from the start, and our attorneys can step in right away when an internal investigation is needed to gather it.

Can a Vessel Owner Limit Its Liability After a Crew Injury?

A vessel owner can ask a federal court to cap its liability at the value of the vessel and its pending freight, meaning the freight the voyage was earning. Under Section 30523 of Title 46, the cap reaches claims that arose without the owner’s privity or knowledge; in plain terms, the owner must not have taken part in the cause or known about it. The cap does not apply to a claim for wages.

For injury and death claims involving seagoing vessels (tugs, towing vessels, barges, fishing vessels, and several other types are excluded), Section 30524 of Title 46 treats what the master, or the owner’s superintendent or managing agent, knew at or before the start of each voyage as the owner’s own knowledge.

What Are the Deadlines on the Defense Side?

The two sides of a maritime injury case work on very different clocks, and the vessel owner’s is far shorter:

ClockDeadline the statute setsWhen it starts
Injured worker’s suit (Section 30106 of Title 46)3 years, except as otherwise provided by lawWhen the cause of action arose
Owner’s limitation action (Section 30529 of Title 46)6 monthsWhen the claimant gives the owner written notice of a claim

A claim letter can start the owner’s clock before any suit is filed. In the Fifth Circuit, which covers Texas, a letter counts as written notice of a claim when it reveals a reasonable possibility that the claim will exceed the vessel’s value.

Coastwise Trade Enforcement: Penalties and Investigations

The coastwise laws bar a vessel from carrying merchandise or passengers between U.S. points unless it is wholly owned by U.S. citizens and either holds a coastwise endorsement (the part of its federal documentation that permits domestic trade) or is exempt from documentation but would otherwise qualify. The merchandise rule in Section 55102 of Title 46 reaches anyone who transports the merchandise or causes it to be transported, so shippers and charterers share the exposure.

ViolationPenalty
Merchandise (Section 55102)Seizure and forfeiture of the merchandise, or the value of the merchandise or the actual cost of the transportation, whichever is greater
Passengers (Section 55103 of Title 46)$300 per passenger under the statute, adjusted for inflation in CBP’s regulation to $996 per passenger landed after November 2, 2015

A defense can start with whether the movement was coastwise transportation at all. Under Section 4.80b of Title 19 of the Code of Federal Regulations, merchandise is not transported coastwise if, at an intermediate port or place outside the coastwise laws, such as a foreign port, it is manufactured or processed into a new and different product before that product travels on to a U.S. point. A party can also ask CBP for a ruling on that question before the cargo moves.

When a Jones Act Matter Becomes a Federal Investigation

A crew injury that needs treatment beyond first aid and leaves the worker unfit for routine duties is also a reportable marine casualty, which can open a Coast Guard investigation. A death aboard can bring criminal exposure for individuals as well as the company.

Under Section 1115 of Title 18 of the U.S. Code, the federal crime often called seaman’s manslaughter, a captain, engineer, pilot, or other person employed on a vessel whose misconduct, negligence, or inattention to duty causes a death faces a fine, up to 10 years in prison, or both. So does an owner or charterer whose fraud, neglect, connivance (knowingly allowing wrongdoing), misconduct, or violation of law causes one. For a corporate owner or charterer, the statute reaches an executive officer charged with controlling and managing the vessel’s operation, equipment, or navigation who knowingly and willfully caused or allowed the violation. The Fifth Circuit has also held that a conviction under this statute does not require proof of gross negligence, unlike ordinary manslaughter.

Our federal criminal defense attorneys handle that side of the matter, from initial inquiries and subpoenas through grand jury proceedings, with the goal of avoiding indictment, preventing prosecution, or securing dismissal whenever possible.

Talk to a Houston Jones Act Defense Attorney

A claim letter, penalty notice, or call from investigators can put a company, a vessel, and an executive’s name at risk together. At Hilder & Associates, P.C., we handle these matters from our Houston office as part of our maritime defense practice.

Contact us today for a free consultation with a Jones Act defense attorney. Call [phonenumber] or reach out online to talk about where your matter stands.